Why these fish are safe to eat frequently
Short answer
Sardines, anchovies, herring, Atlantic mackerel, and trout are the low-mercury ones, being small or short-lived. FDA and EPA rank them among the safest choices, including in pregnancy. Two or three times a week.
What the research shows
Mercury bioaccumulates in large, long-lived predatory fish like tuna, swordfish, and shark. Sardines, anchovies, herring, Atlantic mackerel, and trout are small or short-lived species that accumulate very little mercury. King mackerel is a notable exception.
The FDA and EPA place it on their "choices to avoid" list, so this refers to Atlantic mackerel. The FDA and EPA classify the low-mercury species as among the safest fish choices and recommend them even for pregnant women and young children. Eating these fish two to three times per week is both safe and one of the most nutritionally effective dietary habits available.
Sources
- FDA/EPA (2024). Advice About Eating Fish. fda.gov/food/consumers/advice-about-eating-fish. fda.gov
More on omega-3 and heart health
- Good to know Fatty fish and cardiovascular risk reduction Aim for two servings of fatty fish a week. Meta-analyses link that intake with 15 to 36% lower cardiovascular risk. Plant ALA converts poorly: 5 to 15% becomes EPA and… Mozaffarian & Rimm 2006
- Good to know Omega-3 fatty acids and inflammatory resolution Eat oily fish for the EPA and DHA. Trials consistently show they lower circulating markers of inflammation such as C-reactive protein and interleukin-6. Calder 2017
- Helps absorption Purslane Omega-3, In Proportion Purslane is routinely described as the richest plant source of ALA omega-3 among leafy vegetables, and that ranking is real. The absolute amount is not large. Uddin et al. 2014