Food Agencies Advise Against Hijiki
Short answer
Hijiki is the one seaweed multiple food agencies tell people not to eat. In a UK Food Standards Agency survey of 31 samples across five varieties, inorganic arsenic, the form associated with cancer risk, was found only in the nine hijiki samples.
What the research shows
Hijiki is the one seaweed multiple food agencies tell people not to eat. In a UK Food Standards Agency survey of 31 samples across five varieties, inorganic arsenic, the form associated with cancer risk, was found only in the nine hijiki samples. Arame, kombu, nori and wakame showed none.
Prepared hijiki measured between 7.9 and 30.9 mg per kg, and between 68.8 and 96.2 mg per kg as sold. On that basis the FSA advises consumers not to eat it, and the Canadian and Hong Kong food agencies and Australian authorities give the same advice. It also appears on California's Proposition 65 list.
One honest limit: there is no documented case of anyone being harmed by arsenic from hijiki. The advice rests on how much exposure a normal portion would add, not on reported injury. Soaking and rinsing lowers the level but does not remove it.
Every other seaweed in this corpus tested clean for inorganic arsenic.
Foods this applies to in PairIQ
Applies to (1)
Sources
- UK Food Standards Agency (2004). Survey of total and inorganic arsenic in seaweed, project C02042; Centre for Food Safety, Hong Kong. Hijiki and Arsenic. cfs.gov.hk
More on food safety and limits
- Use care Dried Beans Need a Hard Boil First Dried red kidney beans contain phytohaemagglutinin, a lectin that stays toxic until heat destroys it. Raw beans measure between 20,000 and 70,000 haemagglutinating… FDA Bad Bug Book, Foodborne Pathogenic… 2012
- Use care Cassava Has to Be Peeled and Cooked Cassava contains linamarin, a cyanogenic glycoside. When the root is cut or crushed, an enzyme in the same tissue converts it to hydrogen cyanide, which is why cassava… Food Standards Australia New Zealand
- Use care Bamboo Shoots Are Cooked, Never Raw Fresh bamboo shoots contain cyanogenic glycosides and are not eaten raw. Boiling drives the cyanide off, which is why traditional preparation always starts by boiling… Food Standards Australia New Zealand
- Use care Why taro must always be cooked before eating Never eat taro raw. Its needle-like calcium oxalate crystals carry an irritant that burns the mouth and throat. Cooking inactivates that irritant and makes taro safe… Bradbury & Nixon 1998
- Use care Elderberries Have to Be Cooked Raw elderberries contain sambunigrin, a cyanogenic glycoside, and so do the leaves, bark, stems and roots. Bacteria in the gut cleave the sugar off it and release… Cooperative Extension, Ask Extension
- Use care Rhubarb Stalks Yes, Leaves Never Every part of a rhubarb plant contains oxalic acid, but the leaf blades hold far more of it than the stalks. Purdue Extension puts it plainly: the blades contain toxic… Lerner