Fat-soluble vitamins and carotenoids
Why lettuce is a fat-pairing green, not an iron-pairing one
Short answer
Dress it with real fat, that is what lettuce is for. It is not a vitamin C or calcium source: romaine has about 4mg vitamin C per 100g against kale's 90mg, and 33mg calcium against 250mg.
What the research shows
Lettuce is mostly water. What it does carry, vitamin K1 and in the darker leaves beta-carotene, is fat-soluble, so it needs fat in the same meal to be absorbed at all. Fed the same salad with a full-fat and with a fat-reduced dressing, carotenoid uptake was substantially higher from the full-fat version.
What lettuce does not carry in useful amounts is vitamin C or calcium: romaine has roughly 4mg of vitamin C per 100g against about 90mg for kale, and around 33mg of calcium against about 250mg. Kale and collard greens are the greens that meaningfully lift iron absorption from beans and lentils in the same meal. Lettuce is not one of them, so dress it for the fat-soluble vitamins instead.
Foods this applies to in PairIQ
Where it helps (5)
Sources
- Brown MJ, Ferruzzi MG, Nguyen ML, Cooper DA, Eldridge AL, Schwartz SJ, White WS (2004). Am J Clin Nutr, 80(2):396-403. doi:10.1093/ajcn/80.2.396
More on fat-soluble vitamins and carotenoids
- Helps absorption Why including fat transforms what you absorb from vegetables Add a little olive oil, avocado, eggs, or nuts. Without some fat in the meal, the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K mostly pass straight through. Unlu et al. 2005
- Helps absorption Why fat dramatically changes what you absorb from these vegetables Add olive oil, avocado, or eggs to carrots, sweet potato, or squash. Without fat the carotenoids still absorb, just substantially less. Unlu et al. 2005
- Good to know Why eating these without fat wastes most of their nutritional value Add a little olive oil, nuts, or avocado. The carotenoids in avocado, carrots, sweet potato, and squash absorb substantially less without fat, though not zero. Unlu et al. 2005
- Helps absorption Why fat improves beta-carotene absorption from orange and root vegetables Dress the salad properly. With no oil, carotenoid uptake was negligible. With a little it rose, and with more it rose again, so this is graded rather than a threshold… Brown et al. 2004
- Worth watching Why including fat in this meal matters Add even a small amount of fat. Without it, beta-carotene from carrots and sweet potato absorbs substantially less, though the meal still has value. Unlu et al. 2005
- Helps absorption Why fat improves what you absorb from this fruit Eat it with something fatty. Nuts, avocado, or a little olive oil is enough to get the provitamin A across. Unlu et al. 2005