Why you have to choose between vitamin C and lycopene in tomatoes
Short answer
Raw when iron is the point, cooked with oil when lycopene is. Cooking raises the lycopene but destroys the vitamin C, so you cannot have both in one dish.
What the research shows
Cooking tomatoes increases lycopene bioavailability but destroys vitamin C. These two benefits are in direct opposition. If your goal is supporting iron absorption from a plant-based meal, raw tomatoes are more effective.
If your goal is lycopene intake, cooked tomatoes with oil are better. Understanding this tradeoff lets you use tomatoes strategically: raw in iron-focused meals, cooked in meals where lycopene is the priority.
Foods this applies to in PairIQ
Where to watch it (5)
Sources
- Gärtner C, Stahl W, Sies H (1997). Am J Clin Nutr. doi:10.1093/ajcn/66.1.116
More on preparation and cooking
- Helps absorption Why how you prepare grains changes how much iron you absorb Choose sprouted or sourdough versions when you can. Soaking and pouring off the water helps a little, and plain boiling does nothing at all. Gibson et al. 2006
- Helps absorption Why soaking legumes improves their nutritional value Soak them and throw the water away, since that is where the phytate goes. The gain on whole beans is small. Sprouted or fermented does more. Fernandes et al. 2010
- Helps absorption Why soaking improves what you absorb from nuts and seeds Skip the soaking, it was tested and does not work here. Pair them with a vitamin C food instead, and grind flax seeds rather than eating them whole. Kumari et al. 2020
- Helps absorption Why sprouted-grain bread is not automatically better for minerals Sprouted bread is a fair choice, not a guaranteed one. Across trials the phytate change ran from large drops to small increases depending on grain and conditions… Elliott et al. 2022
- Helps absorption Why fermented teff gives up more of its iron Injera beats plain teff. The long fermentation drops the phytate-to-iron ratio from about 14:1 to about 1:1 over five days, and absorption only improves once it nears… Shumoy et al. 2017
- Helps absorption Why raw carrot gives up so little of its colour Cook it, then chop or puree it. Carrot puree delivered about twice the carotene of boiled and mashed carrot, and none of it works without fat in the same meal. Edwards et al. 2002